cRUISE vs CRUISE GIV ME YOUR OPINION

gogetter · April 30, 2014

8 night on the Liberty...3 ports I have never been to. Closer to home.....OV....Port Canaveral

7 night on Legend...been on this one and to the ports....but get a balcony.....Tampa

20 dollars cheaper on the Legend....

What do you have to say?

Shari2 · April 30, 2014

That would be a tough one for me, gogetter. I really like to have a balcony, but I would want to see other ports, too. If you really liked the ship and ports that you have been to, and really want to have a balcony...go for that one. I would go for the new ports, except at my age I am spoiled now with a balcony...I love the quiet time overlooking the sea; for me, I would keep on looking for something else that I could do both on.

cruisetarp · April 30, 2014

That a tough one but I think I would go for the longer cruise to new ports

KeithnRita · April 30, 2014

I would agree with MaryLou!

Which ever one you choose should be a great cruise!

Jan115 · May 1, 2014

Hi Gogetter - I'd go for the 8-nighter with the ports never seen and the longer cruise. When is the cruise? In the meantime, maybe you can pray for a balcony deal to come along. :biggrin:

gogetter · May 2, 2014

I booked the 8 night Liberty cruise out of Port Canaveral. Grand Turk, Curacao and Aruba. Got an OV for 1327 that includes the prepaid gratuities.

Leaves May 9th so i am a short timer.

jacketwatch · May 5, 2014

We just got off the Legend. Though we had a good time overall I think you will like the Liberty a lot more. Thats the choice I would have made.

zebra · May 6, 2014

I would go for the longer cruise and to see new ports. Also (although we are not avid Carnival fans) we have been on the Legend out of Tampa and didn't like the ship at all. So for us the Liberty would win hands down!